What should you buy? What’s the best sleeping pad out there—and which one should you avoid?
In this article, I’ll walk you through all of that. But more than just naming the best and worst, I’ll also break down which pads are ideal for specific situations.
And if I had to choose just one—no luxury of owning multiple options, just a single pad to use all year long in every condition—I’ll tell you exactly which one I’d pick.
How I Ranked These Sleeping Pads
We are going to pick the worst sleeping pad real quick.
Before we get into that, I want to talk about how I even came to the conclusion of what’s the best and what’s the worst.
I came to that conclusion based on really three things:
- The weight of the sleeping pad.
- The function of the sleeping pad—like what season is it, how well did it sleep, is it warm, is it not warm.
- The price of the sleeping pad—like, what is a good budget sleeping pad? Am I paying too much for it?
The Worst Sleeping Pad
The Sea to Summit Ether Light XT Extreme.
Based on all of those things, the worst sleeping pad for sure is this one here:
The Sea to Summit Ether Light XT Extreme.
I’m going to tell you exactly why this is the worst sleeping pad. There are really two big reasons that are deal-breakers.
The biggest reason is that I froze on this sleeping pad at 20°F—with a foam sleeping pad underneath it—in the wintertime. I was directly on snow, but that never should have happened with this.
Also, this sleeping pad packs down to an enormous size. If you’ve got a lot of stuff in your backpack, this is probably not going to fit in there very well.
It is a comfortable sleeping pad to sleep on, though. So if you’re into just that, that’s fine. They also say that this is a backpacking sleeping pad. There’s no way this is a backpacking pad based on size alone.
As a matter of fact, on their website, they used to say it was a car camping sleeping pad. But now they say it’s a backpacking pad. So there’s that.
Best Budget Pick
The Klymit Static V Insulated.
I think this is probably the best budget sleeping pad on the market. It is ASTM rated at 1.9—which isn’t terrible.
That makes it about a two-season sleeping pad. But it’s wide—23 inches—and costs under $100. Still pretty comfortable for what it is.
Best Ultralight Pad
The Therm-a-Rest UberLite.
If you’re into ultralight—like you want the absolute lightest weight possible—this is probably the best on the market:
The Therm-a-Rest UberLite.
This pad is great for a long-distance hiker. Someone who just wants the lightest weight sleeping pad and gets the best they can out of it.
There are probably better ones on the market, but of the ones I own, this fits that build.
This is a 2.3 R-value pad. So it’s good for fringe seasons—early spring, late fall, possibly.
It should keep you warm down to… but man, it’s lightweight, really comfortable. Not a bad pad.
It’s not my favorite. It’s not the best in my opinion. But it’s certainly a contender.
Most Improved
The Nemo Tensor Insulated Pad (Updated Version).
The Nemo Tensor Insulated Pad got a major performance boost this year—without any noticeable changes in design. Last year’s version had a 3.5 R-value, but the updated model now clocks in at 4.2, making it suitable for four-season use.
That upgrade alone puts it in serious contention for the title of best overall sleeping pad.
Is it the best?
Well… you’ll have to keep reading.
What I can say is that this pad is extremely comfortable. I’ve used the older version for years, and since Nemo sent me the updated model last September, I’ve spent many nights on it. The comfort is still top-tier.
It’s a great pad—no doubt about it.
Bonus Gear: Air Pump
The Air Pump That Just Works
Let’s talk about a piece of gear that made testing all these pads way easier: the Flextail Tiny Gear Pump.
Yes, that’s the one.
With just one charge, I was able to inflate every single sleeping pad I tested. No hand-pumping. No huffing and puffing. Just simple, reliable performance. Pretty solid little tool to have in your kit.
Best Value Right Now
Big Agnes Q-Core SLX.
If you’re looking for an extremely comfortable sleeping pad, budget-friendly, and three-season—this is probably it. It has a 3.2 R-value. So you can take it down to about freezing. It’s also very thick.
And it only costs about $120 right now. These are on sale, which is insane. So this is probably the best buy right now—if you’re shopping today.
Best Comfort
Big Agnes Rapide SL.
This is pretty much identical to the Q-Core SLX. The only major difference? This one has a higher R-value: 4.5. So it’s really competitive with the Nemo Tensor.
The difference between this and the Nemo? They’re both similar in R-value, weight, and size—but this one is more comfortable, in my opinion. It’s a little bit thicker. And the raised sides kind of hold you on the pad.
Some people don’t like that. I do. It makes the pad feel wider than it is. This is possibly the best sleeping pad I’ve ever bought.
Best for Cold Weather
Therm-a-Rest NeoAir XTherm.
I’ve had this pad for many years. It was one of my first backpacking pads. It might be the best. Here’s why: it has the best warmth-to-weight ratio of any pad I’ve seen. It’s a 6.9 R-value sleeping pad.
I’ve taken it to ridiculous cold temps directly on snow and stayed warm. It’s not as comfortable as some others—but for what it is, it’s awesome. It’s also really durable. The nylon is thick. You can toss it around and not worry about punctures.
Leave a Comment